Showing posts with label Medlin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Medlin. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Eaten By Hogs: The Fate of Frank McMillan

 



Frank McMillan was a good man. He met an unconscionable fate. Finding his story, which took place high in the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina, near the Tennessee border and the Cherokee Reservation, linked back to Stanly and Anson Counties in the southern Piedmont of North Carolina, down not one, but multiple, trails. This is his story. 

Joseph Frank McMillan was born on April 5, 1846, in a place called Beaverdam, Cherokee County, North Carolina. His mother's name was Milly McMillan. Some have her with the maiden name Allen and tie her to a 19-year-old still living with her family in 1850, but that doesn't add up. Her oldest three children were born prior to that time. Just a few years prior to 1860, she was listed in a roll or census of Cherokee, as a descendant of a Cherokee man named William Murphy, including her oldest three children, of which "Joseph" was one of the three.



By the 1860 census of Beaverdam, Cherokee County, Millie has 6 children, William 15, Rachel 13, Joseph 11, Stacy 9, Caroline 11, and Nancy 6 months old. She is sandwiched in between families of Murphy's. John and James Murphy are listed above her, and Mary and Jesse head the families listed below her. I would think a better guess would be that Millie may have been a Murphy. Her husband is unknown, an unknown McMillan. Not all of her children may have been his children. The census also indicates a lifestyle of movement. Millie, herself was born in Macon County, NC. Her oldest son, William, was born in Cherokee County, NC. Her second child, Rachel, was born in Monroe County, Tennessee. Joseph was born back in Cherokee, while his sister, Stacy, was born in Bradley County, Tennessee. The youngest two girls, Caroline and Nancy were born back in Cherokee. 



There was a McMillan family in Bradley County at the time Stacy was born, and a household headed by a Joseph McMillan, who may have been related.

The woman next door, Mary, was born in Elbert County, Georgia. Mary's story left pervasive imprint on this community for generations, and she deserves her own post. Frank McMillon grew up in a community of white, indigenous and mixed-race people. The name McMillon would change at times in the mountains, phonetically, in the same way Yarbrough or Yarborough had become 'Yarber'. It would be, variantly, seen as 'Medlin', while referring to the same people. Medlin was an entirely different name.

In 1870, Millie is still living in the same area, just two households up from Martin Murphy, a son of Mary Murphy. She has three daughters with her, Rachel, Caroline and Barbara, and a one-year-old, Emma. Emma may have been a daughter, or a granddaughter.



At the top of the page, Mary Murphy is counted as 80 years old and was living with her son Elijah, still.


Phoebe Murphy, wife of her son, Jesse, was living next to her. This did not mean Jesse was deceased.

More Murhpy's led in from the previous page.  This was the household of Mary's sons, David and James. She had many sons. 



It is easy to see the long and entangled connections the family of Millie McMillan had to the Murphy family. Sometimes the Murphy's were labeled as Indian, other times they were labeled as white, the opinion of the census-taker, I would imagine.



Cherokee County is the westernmost southern county in North Carolina, bordering both East Tennessee and North Georgia, and very close to South Carolina, too. It's residents wove in and around all three states with ease and ignorance, not always certain what state or county they were exactly in. 

Another theory on the origins of Millie McMillen, and therefore, Frank McMillan, was that she was born a McMillen, and never married at all. There was a James McMillan and wife, Millie Waters, both born about 1792. John was born in Virginia, and Millie Waters was born in Mecklenburg County, NC. They married in Haywood County, NC on October 6, 1817.

NameJoseph Mcmullen
Residence Date1840
Home in 1840 (City, County, State)Cherokee, North Carolina
Free White Persons - Males - Under 51
Free White Persons - Males - 15 thru 191
Free White Persons - Males - 20 thru 291
Free White Persons - Males - 40 thru 491
Free White Persons - Females - Under 51
Free White Persons - Females - 5 thru 91
Free White Persons - Females - 10 thru 141
Free White Persons - Females - 15 thru 191
Free White Persons - Females - 30 thru 391
Free White Persons - Females - 60 thru 691
Persons Employed in Agriculture1
No. White Persons over 20 Who Cannot Read and Write2
Free White Persons - Under 206
Free White Persons - 20 thru 493
Total Free White Persons10
Total All Persons - Free White, Free Colored, Slaves10

The family had settled in Cherokee County, NC by 1840. It appears, at that time, they may have been the parents of six children, and had brought one of their mothers with them, as a woman in her 60's lived with them. 







They are found all the way to 1870, as octogenarians, living in the town of Murphy, Cherokee County, North Carolina. Nothing more is seenof them past 1870. What is known is that Joseph was the son of Joseph McMillan, Sr. (1756-1844), and wife, Nancy; and Millie was the daughter of Johann Michael Waters (Wieder) and wife, Permelia Stewart. Michael Waters lived in Cabarrus County, NC, part of the German Community that had settled along Dutch Buffalo Creek and his wife was a member of the Mecklenburg County, Scottish derived, Stewart family, daughter of John and Mary Ann Davis Stewart. The McMillans were the parents of the following known children: Mary aka "Polly" McMillan, who married James Marion "Jim" Murphy, a son of Mary Murphy, Joseph McMillan III, who married Teresa Doughit, and Cassa Caroline McMillan who married John Calhoun Morris and David Murphy, another son of Mary Murphy. It makes tremendous sense that Millie might be another daughter of this family, especially since her name was Millie, and she was surrounded by Murphy's.

But back to Frank. We know we first see him as a 14-year-old, living in his mother's household in Beaverdam, Cherokee County, surrounded by Murphy's. 

On January 24, 1870, he married Lydia M. Roberts, daughter of Richard Roberts and Caroline Guthrie Roberts. Their first child, William, is born four months later in May. This was not a particularly devout or strictly moral part of the state. In the high mountains, marriage was sometimes optional and transportation so limited, lifestyles were different. 


They are living next to Martin Murphy, and one page over from a number of other Murphys. Frank was a Civil War Veteran. His wife Lydia would later file and receive a pension for his service. 



By 1880, the McMillan household has moved away from the immediate vicinity of the Murphy's, although, they are still in Beaverdam and still in Cherokee County.


NameFrank Mc Millian
Age35
Birth DateAbt 1845
BirthplaceNorth Carolina
Home in 1880Beaver Dam, Cherokee, North Carolina, USA
Dwelling Number144
RaceWhite
GenderMale
Relation to Head of HouseSelf (Head)
Marital StatusMarried
Spouse's NameLydia Mc Millian
Father's BirthplaceNorth Carolina
Mother's BirthplaceNorth Carolina
OccupationFarmer
NeighborsView others on page
Household members
NameAge
Frank Mc Millian35
Lydia Mc Millian26
William Lafayette Mc Millian10
Alice Mc Millian8
Mary Mc Millian6
Charlotta Mc Millian4
David Mc Millian7/12

By this time, the family is up to five children. William, ten, whose middle name, we learn in Lafayette, was followed by Alice, 8, Mary, 6, Charlotte, 4, and David, just 7 months. Chances are, one passed away between Charlotte and David, as the pattern was typically one every two or three years. 

The family would remain in Cherokee County, and the final tally of children grew to eight. Below is a photo made circa the early 1890's, of the Frank and Lydia McMillan family, all eight children and two sons-in-laws. 


The names were credibly written on the back of the photo.

Front row was David, born 1879, Rebecca, born 1881, Marinda, born 1885, their mother, Lydia, born 1853, holding John Jesse, born around 1888. In back, from left to right, was Alice Cordelia, born in 1874, and her husband, George Washington Morrow; Mary Caroline, born 1875, and her husband, Samuel "Dub" Morrow; two sisters married to tow brothers. followed by third daughter, Charlotte Victoria, born in 1877 and oldest son, William Lafayette McMillan, born in 1870, the child that would incendiate the union. Note: Several of the children's marriage licenses, like those of Alice and Charlotte, gave their surnames as 'Medlin'.


And then, in April of 1891, Frank went to his sister's wedding.


The Wilson Advance

Wilson, North Carolina  Thursday, April 28, 1892


Tellico Mountain is part of the Nantahala National Forrest, in the northwest corner of Cherokee County, just outside of the town of Murphy and near the Georgia and Tennessee borders. It's known for it's high, rugged terrain, part of the Unicoi range, carved out by the Tellico river and it's many connected streams. It was also the known hideout of a number of dangerous men, and part of the Murphy family that Frank McMillan had grown up with. The newspapers declared that William "Bill"  Murphy, a son of Civil War Veteran, Archibald Murphy, sr. and a Grandson of Polly Murphy, mentioned previously, claimed he desired to kill ten men. He started with his own brother. George Murphy was marrying , or in the process of marrying, a sister of Frank Medlin/McMillen. The newspapers declared that her father, unnamed, had been an enemy of the family. It is unknown who their father was. Only mother Millie held them together. Frank, a good man, as I mentioned leading into this story, gave his newly deceased brother-in-law a decent burial. This act of kindness angered the murdering brother of the deceased.

William "Bill" Murphy was born around 1864/1865, posthumously to his father, Archibald, a Civil War casualty, and his mother, Frances "Fanny" Dunning Murphy. He was the youngest of the children of this pair, which consisted of brothers, John, James, Archibald Jr., George and William and sister, Minnie. Fannie may have been previously married to a Haskins or was born a Haskins who married a Dunning. That, I've not worked out.

The family was a bit of a quirk, even among their mixed community of Cherokee, White and intermarried families of these two races. Polly Murphy, a story of her own, had children with a number of white, Cherokee and one black man. The black man is unnamed but was thought to have been the son of a Cherokee man and African-descended mother. Polly, herself, was either white or a mix of white and Cherokee. The son she had with African ancestry was Archibald Murphy, Sr. Fanny, the wife of Archibald, was white. It seems this particular multi-racial branch of the greater Murphy family was ostracized and shamed, perhaps causing the sons to grow into angry young men.

Fanny Murphy and her youngest four sons in 1870, after the death of her husband.

The fact that Frank McMillan gave the groom a decent burial angered Bill, or angered the brother that killed George, which we will get to momentarily, causing the killer to make Frank his second victim. Frank was ambushed, when Murphy, who had been watching him from the bushes, jumped out and mortally shot him. There are different versions; that it occurred during the wedding, or sometime after the wedding, the details there are murky.

Whenever the occurrence, there were multiple folks in attendance, as it was said Murphy sprang out onto the road, defying anyone to attend to the fallen man. The corpse of Frank McMillen/Medlin had come to the attention of a group of hogs, probably wild hogs that roamed the mountains, but perhaps those kept by either the Murphy or McMillan family. A Mr. Morse and his wife moved towards Frank to guard him, and the wife was shot by Murphy, allowing the hogs to take Frank's body as their evening meal. At the time of the article, Mrs. Morse was not yet dead, but in a critical condition. 

Bill wasn't done. He escaped to the house of a Mr. Bailey and demanded to be housed or hidden. Bailey didn't respond well enough and was shot in the shoulder. On April 27, 1892, he claimed a fifth victim in the person of Ben Martin, who had rightfully been critical of the madman's behavior. Murphy caught Mr. Martin working at his farm and shot him dead. 

There were varying accounts of the events and the story.


Newspapers.com - The Charlotte Observer - 29 Nov 1892 - 2

In November of 1892, seven months after the wedding murders, the above article appeared in The Charlotte Observer. They stated that Bill, who had been presumed dead, was alive, hiding in the high mountains. He supposedly headed a gang of miscreants and criminals. Several things in the article do not add up. It stated that Bill had been terrorizing the community for three decades, and that in 1862, at fifteen, with a dozen other gang members, had ridden 'into town', the town not named, but perhaps the town of Murphy, named for a man named Archibald Murphy, coincidentally, but not their father or kin. Bill wasn't even born yet in 1862. They may have been talking about his father, or an uncle. They claimed Archibald, the father, married an "Indian Squaw". That remains to be seen. Arch, himself, was tri-racial, but Fannie was counted in census records as white. The story involving the murders of George Murphy and Frank McMillan were recounted as a disagreement between two brothers who both wanted to marry one woman.



Another version of the events' claimed George was killed for committing a mesalliance, or, a marriage with a person thought to be unsuitable, or of a lower class, because the McMillans, Medlin's, or whomever their father was, had been in a feud, or an enemy of, the Murphy's. This one, with a bit more gore and flourish, expanded upon the fact that a group of hungry hogs 'began to mutilate the body'  of  Frank Medlin/McMillen, that Mr. and Mrs. Morse had moved in to protect Frank, against the orders of mad Murphy, resulting in Mrs. Morse's death and Mr. Morse's injury.


The Leaf-Chronicle

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle

Clarksville, Tennessee Wednesday, April 06, 1892



A Tennessee Newspaper told a similar version.


The Nashville Banner reported that a award of $250 each, had been offered for not one, but two Murphy brothers, adding Archibald "Arch" Jr. to the crime. 






Six years later, it is discovered that Arch Murphy was the one brought to trial and given a very light sentence, a detail noted by the court and the paper. Archie was sentenced to ten years in prison for 'murder in the first degree with mitigating circumstances for the killing of Frank Medlin".  He was sentenced to life and appealed.  He had been captured in Monroe County, Tennessee and tried there. There will be more on the Murphy's in another post.

The tale of the murder of Frank Medlin/McMillan rose as many questions as it answered. Some remain a mystery. First to mind was what was the nascence of the fissure between the Murphy and Mcmillan families? What event had caused such hostility that it had erupted into murder? The second question, that may be deducted through the process of elimination, was which sister married George Murphy and inadvertently became the impetus for murder? The last question, that I've not been able to break is, exactly who was the father of the McMillen children?

The family of Frank McMillan, in the photos above, appear to be an average Appalachian mountain family of the Victorian era, of British Isle descent. They were, to an extent. Their mother, specifically, seems to have had no other ancestry, except European. Frank, however, was of mixed ancestry.






Millie McMillen was counted in not one, but two rosters of people with Native heritage. She was counted by the Commission to the Five Civilized Tribes, as a member of the Chickasaw Tribe.






In the Guion Miller rolls, Millie, in a household with three others, Sina, John and Joseph. Rachel Hall, her oldest daughter and her children, and Stacy Graham, another daughter, and her children, are included in group of England Point and Ducktown Cherokee, as descendants of William Murphy. William Murphy, also known as Whiplash, or by his Cherokee name, Cowstaneesta, was a husband of Mary Polly Riley Murphy, the mother of Arch Murphy, Senior. So, there were strong family connections between the two families, with Millie being a Murphy who married a McMillan. If she was not a daughter of Mary, she was at least a stepdaughter of sorts. Archibald Murphy was not a son of Whiplash, but one of Mary. The entanglements were strong. 

This puts Frank at being one quarter Cherokee.







Frank's daughter, Rebecca, married an Almond. More on that in a minute. However, when she died of TB in 1940, she named her father as Frank Medlin, yet he was always in the census as Frank McMillan. Several daughters are also seen as Medlins in their marriage licenses. 








His military records state McMillen, as does his application for a military tombstone, which was granted. In this, I believe I may have discovered a cause for friction between the two families.







Frank McMillan, at 18, had enlisted in Roan County, Tennessee, for the Union Army. Archibald Murphy, Sr., father of the Murphy boys who would murder him at age 45, fought for the Confederacy. 


He died on November 18, 1864, of wounds received on November 3rd, of the same month




His widow would go on to marry a Cooper and applied for a pension based on his service. If the 'rebels' who had wounded Archibald Murphy been tied to the Unit Frank McMillan had served in, which I believe it may have, this could have been the incident that could create a decades long feud.

As far as which sister could have been marrying George Murphy in 1892, we can rule out Rachel, the oldest, who married John Martin Hall in 1870, and stayed married to him until her death in 1910. Second oldest, Stacy L. McMillan married Napolean Bonaparte Graham in 1869, and remained married to him until her death in 1908. Caroline McMillen, I have not nailed down yet. Josephine Florence "Josie" McMillan, who has not been mentioned yet, and may have been "Barbara" as she was born in 1861, yet she is not on the 1870 census with Millie, but Barbara is. There are also the mysteries of Nancy and Emmaline, who don't show up again. But the mysteries grow. Caroline was the most likely candidate.


Josie married Henry Andrew Dockery, lived in Polk County, Tennessee for awhile and died in 1929 in Liberty, Cherokee County, NC. We can rule her out. 

The oldest of Millies's children, William, seems to have not married until September 1, 1894, when at age 45, he wed Nancy C. Hartness. They farmed in the Notla community of Cherokee County, NC until William's death in 1923. Nancy would go on to marry a C. L. Hogsed. William left a Will and willed nearly everything to his beloved wife, Nancy, his farm, his livestock, his equipment and wagons, and household furniture. He did bequeath a token amount to his siblings and their heirs.



He left one dollar each to the heirs of Rachel Hall. the heirs of Stacy L. Graham, the heir of Caroline McMillan, to Josey Dockery and her heirs, (the way this was worded indicates she was still living), to Carra Cash heir, one dollar and to John McMillon (living) and his heirs one dollar. "the aforesaid being my brothers and sisters and their heirs." He didn't mention Frank. 




I discovered Josie Dockery, because William and Nancy lived right beside them in the 1900 census. Josie doesn't appear until 1900 in records. The mountaineers were missed often. Carra McMillan Cash and her heir, and the Caroline McMillan and her heir, remain a mystery. Could Carra be Sina, mentioned in the Miller count living with Millie? Could she have been the child, Emma, in the 1870 census with Millie?




William also left a Death Certificate, but the informant, W. E. Graham, a nephew, didn't know the name of his parents. 

The youngest McMillen, John Lafayette McMillon, was born after the 1870 census. Millie was missed in 1880.. This may have been the time of birth of the mystery sisters, after the 1870 census.
John was born on January 31, 1876. Millie would have been 45 years old.





He is first found living with the Allen family, which I will also explore in a later post. I will say here that the nephew connection is through the Matoy family, which Mary Polly Riley Murphy's oldest son, William R. Matoy, was the progenitor of. He married Barbara Hartness, sister of William's wife, Nancy, daughters of Thomas Hartness and wife, Sarah Runyan. They lived awhile in Polk County, Tennessee, and Knoxville, before returning to Notla, in Cherokee County in 1900, where William and Josie lived. They went back to Polk in 1910 and 1920, then decided to retire to Florida in 1930, they remained in Florida until after 1940, then wanted to return home to Cherokee County, where John passed in 1950.





John also had a Death Certificate. His informant was Jack McMillan, his son, of Murphy, NC. Jack named his father's parents as John McMillon and Millie (Mellie) Medlin. Was this the nominal "John Doe" sort of John, often substituted in cases of illegitimacy to avoid embarrassment, or was there really a John McMillan. And there is the name Medlin again. Millie McMillen died January 31, 1905, in Cherokee County, North Carolina. 


In 1900, Lydia Roberts, the widow of Joseph Frank McMillan, is living in Beaverdam, Cherokee County, NC, among her Roberts relatives. 



At the bottom of the page is the homestead of George Washington "Allman" or Almond. 

George Washington Almond was the son of John Decatur Almond and wife, Talitha Adelaide Sherman.

John Decatur Almond of Tillman Almond and wife, Delina Lindia Killan. 

Tillman Almond was born in 1815 in Montgomery, now Stanly, County, North Carolina, near the Cabarrus County line, to Pleasant Almond and Rebecca Lambert Almond, my fourth Great Aunt. They had come to Cherokee County with their father, Pleasant, after he and Rebecca parted ways, but he returned to Stanly County before he died. They had never divorced. A group of McLures from Stanly and Cabarrus Counties had accompanied them. Rebecca's younger sister, Piety Caroline, had married a McLure. Many Almonds and McLures remain in Cherokee County. 

One of Joseph Franklin McMillan's daughters married a Stanly County Almond. Another female Stanly County Almond married a Murphy. Her tale will be told. 

The children of poor Frank McMillen/ Medlin, who tragically became food for the hogs, and his wife, Lydia, who passed peacefully in 1922 and was buried in Unaka, Cherokee County, were:

William Lafayette McMillan (1870-1940) Married Ada Davis, 5 children. Farmed most of his life in Cherokee County. Died in Habersham, Georgia.
Alice Cordelia McMillen (1874-1950) Married George Washington Morrow, six children. Remained in Cherokee County. 
Mary Caroline McMillen (1875-1946) Married Samuel David "Dunn" Morrow. Nine children. Remained in Cherokee.
Charlotte Victoria "Lottie" McMillen/Medlin (1877-1953) Married Cicero Judson Bryson.Six children. Moved to Gaston County, but returned to Cherokee.
James David McMillan (1879-1967) Married Georgia Reed, no children. Married second Lillian Moss, eight children. Raised family in Cherokee County. Lived last years in Swain. 
Rebecca Josephine McMillen (1888-1940). 

Rebecca is the one who married into the Almond family and her children were descendants of Rev. John Lambert of Liberty Hill Primitive Baptist Church. 
She married John Allen Almond, son of John Decatur Almond and Mary Alice Miller. 


Marriage of John Allen Almond and Rebecca McMillon, daughter of Frank

Rebecca and John had five children: Alma, Jesse, George, Henry and Bruner. She was his second wife. He had one daughter, Dessie, by his first wife, Rosalie. Rebecca died in Robbinsville, Graham County, NC, but was returned to Cherokee for burial.

John Jesse McMillen Sr. (1891-1971) Married Edith Bates, nine children. Remained in Unaka, Cherokee County, NC.

Lucy Marinda McMillen (1891-1957) Never married Two children, a son and daughter. Remained in Murphy, Cherokee County. Lived with Lydia until her mother's death. Her son went by Medlin instead of McMillen. Her daughter married, but as a McMillen.



The husband of Stacy L. McMillen Graham, N. B. Graham, would remarry and fittling move to Graham, NC. Their descendants would relocate to the North Carolina Piedmont, and one to Oklahoma.