Friday, November 20, 2026

All of Millie's Babies: The Heir of Caroline

 


Millie McMillen was born around 1830 in Macon County, North Carolina.


It says as much in the 1860 census of Cherokee County, North Carolina, a few counties west of Macon on the western border with Tennessee and the northernmost border of Georgia. She was 15 years old when her oldest son, William R. was born in 1845 in Cherokee County. Her daughter, Rachel Louisa, was born in Monroe County, Tennessee in 1847, her son, Joseph Frank was born in 1849 back in Cherokee County, NC. Millie's second daughter Stacy was born in 1851 in Bradley County, Tennessee, where she had brothers and other kin. She was followed by Caroline, who was born in 1853 in Cherokee again, with Nancy born in 1859. Nancy probably died as a child, as she never appears again. Millie will continue to have children. In 1860, she is surrounded by the Murphy family.



The only McMillan in 1830, the year Millie was born, in Macon County, was Joseph McMillen. There were no Murphys. I had toyed with the idea that Millie may have been a Murphy who married a McMillen. In 1860, she could have been a widow whose husband had died in 1859.



By 1870, she has added two more children; Barbara, who she was probably already pregnant with in1860, born in North Carolina, and Emma, born in 1859 in Tennessee, but here she is again in Cherokee County, NC, back among the Murphy's. Her dead husband could not have sired that last one.  And Emma was not her last.

I am now of the opinion that Millie must have been born a McMillen, and much like her neighbor, Polly Murphy, her children may have had multiple fathers.



Cherokee was a burned County, one where Courthouse fires ravished crucial family records. There is a quiet, profound sadness in the loss of records to courthouse fires- an irreversible erasure of the ordinary lives that once filled those pages. Births and deaths, marriages and land deeds, wills and court testimonies: each document was a fragile thread connecting families across generations, proving who owned what, who inherited from whom, who had legally disputed one thing or another, orphans bound or assigned guardians, who had been brought to court for wrong-doings - including unwed mothers. When flames consume those papers, entire branches of a family tree can vanish into smoke, leaving descendants scratching our heads, wanting answers to questions that may never fully be resolved.

One source we do still have are the enrollment records of the Eastern Cherokee. During 1838 and 1839, the Cherokee living in western North Carolina, North Georgia, and East Tennessee, were rounded up by the US Army and forced to walk to a reservation in Oklahoma along with members of the Choctaw, Chickasaw and Creek. Some of them escaped, taking refuge among non-native neighbors, or climbing so high into the Blue Ridge Mountains that even the armed forces gave up on these few stragglers. The descendants of these getaways became known as the Eastern Cherokee.  Guion Miller was one of the officials tasked with taking a count of these individuals. Millie McMillan was among those on his list in 1884.

NameMillie McMillan
Birth Yearabt 1834
Age50
Record Date1884
Record PlaceEngland's Point, North Carolina

She was age 50 and living at a place called England's Point, North Carolina.



On the above roll, Stacy L Graham and Rachel Hall are daughters of Millie McMillan. They have given William Murphy as their ancestor on previous rolls. I at first though this may have meant that Millie had been a Murphy, but after a deeper investigation into it, I believe they may have indicating that William Murphy was their father, as I don't believe Millie ever married. This count gives Stacy's age as 30, the W on the left border indicated the relationship to the person on the left side, N B. Graham, white, her husband, so "W" meant wife, followed by S, S, S, and 10, 6, 5, ages of SONS, William H. James R. and Edward M.




In the 1880 census, Stacy and her husband, Napolean Bonaparte Graham, a schoolteacher and trader, are found in Polk County, Tennessee, just across the border from Cherokee County, with sons William Houston, born in 1875 and James Robert, born in 1877. Edward Morton Graham was born in 1880, so the ages and names correspond.


Rachel was shown in the 1884 roll as Rachel Hall, 34, with four children, William, Nellie, Alice and John, ages 10, 8, 6, and 2. 

In the 1880 census, Rachel and her husband, John M. Hall, were also living in Polk County, Tennessee, with their three oldest children, William,6,  Nellie,4,  and Alice,1. John's sister, Frances was living with them and John was a Smelter man by trade.

In the Miller Roll, Millie McMillan's household consisted of Millie, 50, Sina, 24, John 13, and Joseph, 3. There are no letters to the left of Millie's name to describe the relationship, nor does this household appear in the 1880 census. Millie was either ignored, missed, or she had hidden from the census taker.

I was uncertain, at the time, of who 'Sina' was. I knew by this time, after the discovery of the Will of William McMillan, that John, born in 1876, was Millie's son, John Lafayette McMillan. But who was three-year-old Joseph?

There was one other line in this grouping to keep in mind. 



Between Rachel, Stacy and Millie was W. C. Graham, on the left, and his wife, Sarah, listed on the right. The significance of these individuals will be seen momentarily. One might wonder if W. C. Graham was related to N. B. (Napolean Bonaparte) Graham, the husband of Stacy McMillion. There was a relation. A very complicated relation. His wife, Sarah, was not related to the McMillans She just happened to be listed in amongst them.


Cherokee Town Locations in Red

Scattered like jewels amid the mist-veiled ridges, Cherokee towns clung to the ancient folds of Tennessee, North Carolina and Georgia, and less so into South Carolina, their hearth-fires flickering across borders that held no meaning for the. Linked together by social and familial networking, and timeworn paths that wound through laurel thickets and along babbling streams, these highland villages held an older kinship, one the mountains still encompassed in the middle 19th century. Whether Millie and her descendants were in Isabella or Ducktown, in Polk County, Tennessee, or England Point and Hanging Dog, in Cherokee County in North Carolina, or any of the assorted tiny villages like Fighting Town or Sugartown in North Georgia, they were still in a tight knit, interrelated community




Rachel Louisa McMillan Hall will also appear in another list of Cherokee petitioners, while living in Isabella, Tennessee. In this count, she was the mother of only one child, thus far, and her claim was rejected, because she filed as a descendant of Polly Murphy. Mary Polly Riley or Reilly Murphy was the wire that would bring this team altogether. Polly was known as a white woman, or mixed woman, who had at least nine children by multiple men of various races. We've now determined that Millie McMillons children, at least some of them, were the children of William Murphy, who was, in turn, the son of Polly Murphy. She could not have been a Great Grandmother, she was barely old enough to be a grandmother.



Isabella was part of a wide-spread mining community and sat right upon the Tennessee- North Carolina border. Mining was probably a big draw, bringing people from all corners into the previously isolated coves and hollers. It also provided income for the traditional citizens and descendants of early settlers. 


Currently, Isabella is defined as a hamlet, located north of Highway 64, still surrounded by mines and lying in between Belltown and Ducktown, former Cherokee villages.



Above is a graphic of how far the Cherokee lands had spread. Joseph McMillan had been an invader. The Reilly women were another story entirely. 

William Matoy

William Murphy was also known William R. Matoy, his preferred name. His full name was much longer. Born in 1819, William also bore the Cherokee name of We-li-ah, and the nickname of Chief Bill. He was the son of James "Oo-wah-gah" or "Jim" Matoy, Sr. and Mary "Polly" Reilly Murphy. His father died in 1836, during the removal, or shortly after. Despite having a number of children with Millie McMillan, William Matoy married a Smith and had an equal number of children with her. He served in the Civil War and afterwards removed himself to the Delaware District to claim his lands as a member of the Cherokee tribe. He died there in 1900. I will give more information on him in another post. 

So, William Matoy, or Murphy, was at least Cherokee to some degree. With Polly Murphy's many children, their identity must have been a headache for the men charged with making the decisions on who qualified and who did not.

But back to the 1884 Guinn Miller roll. Remember the little boy, three-year-old Joseph? I went on a mission to find out who he was. I found the following on Find-A-Grave.


Joseph was the son of Carolina 'Lina' McMillan and William C. Graham.

His obit said that he was survived by his wife, Nora Roulette, a son George, and a daughter Mary Elizabeth. He also had four stepdaughters, Violet Butler, Mrs. Alvin Baker, Jr., Mrs. Fletcher Green, and Mrs. Howard Long.

His memorial services were held at Lone Oak Baptist Church, with the Rev. Walker officiating. Burial was in Cedar Cemetery.

Local residents say Cedar is the cemetery located just behind Memorial Funeral Home at the corner of Morganton and Big Springs Road across from a Mini-Mart. A new church was built in 1946 at another location.

No marker has been found for Joseph.


Joseph Houston McMillen was the son of Carolina 'Lina' McMillen/ McMillon. Sina was not Sina, but Lina. Joseph was the one heir of Caroline McMillen mentioned in her brother William's will.



In William McMillen's Will, who died childless in 1923, everything was left to his wife, Nancy Hartness McMillen, except nominal nods to his siblings, and their heirs. He had survived most of his siblings and the way he worded the gift to his sister, Caroline, or Carolina, 'and to the heir of Caroline', it was clear he had survived her, and she had left one heir, not heirs. She had kept the name McMillen, as did her son, so she was not married. Her son's father was William C Graham. Where had we seen that name before? 

William C Graham


The first place we had seen William C. Graham was in the 1880 census of Polk County, Tennessee. He was living as a boarder with James L. Graham, working in the mines, and living two houses down in the list from Napolean B. Graham and wife, Stacy L. McMillan Graham.

The second place was in the 1884 Guinn Miller Roll, with his wife, Sarah, no children. Caroline and Joseph were listed right afterwards, living with Millie and her youngest son, John.

William Crosier Graham in old age.


William Crosier Graham was born July 3, 1855, in Cherokee County, NC. He was the son of William Edward Graham (1819-1869) and Mary Ann Matoy Graham (1833-1913). Ah yes, and there is that Matoy name again.

William Edward Graham was a white man who was born in Rutherford County, NC and had moved to Monroe County, Tennessee by 1836. He married Margaret Buchanan around 1840 and with her had three sons, one of whom was Napolean Bonaparte Graham, who married Stacy McMillan. 


He is found in the 1850 census of Polk County, Tennessee in 1850, working as a boot and shoemaker. With him is Margaret and their three boys. In 1860, he is in Sweetwater, Monroe County, TN, still as a shoemaker. He died in 1869 in Cherokee County, NC.





He was buried at the Old First Baptist Church in Murphy. His relationship with Mary Ann Matoy is sketchy. There are no marriage records, but she, and her son, bore his name. This makes William C. Graham a half-brother to Napolean B. Graham.





William first shows up in the 1870 census of Cherokee County in 1870. He's 15, and his mother is head of household. Her sister, Nancy, lives with them, with her daughter, Isabel. They are right next door to Millie McMillen. Caroline is 14. So, they were very familiar with each other. William's mother, Mary Ann Matoy Graham, is where it gets interesting. She was the daughter of William R. Matoy, aka "Cheif Bill".  'Memba him? 

So, at least Rachel and Stacy McMillan were daughters of Chief Bill, if not Caroline. Mary Ann Matoy was his daughter with his legal wife Martha Smith Matoy. This makes the children of Mary Ann Matoy and those of Millie McMillan fathered by Chief Bill, half-siblings. Caroline was younger than Rachel and Stacy, maybe it was known to them that Caroline, "Lina", was not Cheif Bill's child, but it's still malbehavior and a bit creepy.

William Crosier Graham would marry Sarah L. Bryant, move to Delaware, Oklahoma, on the reservation, and have an enormous family of 16 children. Joseph was not lacking in siblings, biologically, he just did not grow up with them. Over the course of 25 years, Crosier and Sarah had Genetta, Sarah, Stacy and Nellie (twins), Minnie and Hardee (twins), Mollie and Ulysses (twins), Eunice, Hugh, Annie and Edward (twins), Lucy, William and ending with Stella and Ella, also twins. I had to name them, it was just so, intriguing. Reminds me of these huge families on social media with multiple sets of multiples. 

He took his mother with him, who married Samuel Nelson Melton after the death of William Edward Graham, and they both died in Oklahoma. Below is Mary's inclusion in the Department of the Interior, Commission to the Five Civilized Tribes. She was admitted as a member of the Cherokee tribe. 




Joseph Houston McMillen was born on July 17, 1880 in Ducktown, Polk County, Tennessee.


NameJoseph Mc Millon
Age in 191029
Birth Date1881
BirthplaceTennessee
Home in 1910Civil District 8, Polk, Tennessee, USA
Sheet Number8b
StreetVillage of Ducktown
RaceWhite
GenderMale
Relation to Head of HouseHead
Marital StatusMarried
Father's BirthplaceTennessee
Mother's BirthplaceTennessee
Native TongueEnglish
OccupationMiner
IndustryCopper Mine
Employer, Employee or OtherWage Earner
Home Owned or RentedRent
Farm or HouseHouse
Able to readY
Able to WriteY
Enumeration District Number0163
Years Married6
Out of WorkN
Number of Weeks Out of Work0
Enumerated Year1910
NeighborsView others on page
Household members
NameAge
Joseph Mc Millon29
Lizzie Mc Millon31
Venice W Mc Millon3
William Juner35


Joe first shows up as an adult in the 1910, working as a Miner in a Copper Mine in Ducktown. He has a wife named Lizzie, and a three-year-old 'adopted' child, a boy named Venice. He is counted as a white man. He will marry a widow, Norabell Roulette Butler Foster, and become the a stepfather of four girls, Violet, Phacia, Josie and Jenny. They will have two children of their own, George Washington McMillen in 1931 and Mary Elizabeth McMillen in 1935. It is unknown when or where his mother died. 




In 1930 and 1940, Joe is found in Blount Couty, Tennessee.

He applied as a Cherokee descendant for a pension paid the tribe. He was disqualified as a descendant of Polly Murphy.



Above is a chart of descendancy from Polly Murphy, drawn up by an individual working from the Dawes Roll to determine who was descended from whom.




Joe died on July 27, 1944, in Marysville, Blount County, Tennessee. He was a 59-year-old Apple Peddler. 



The Knoxville Journal

Knoxville, Tennessee Thursday, June 29, 1944



He was also the heir of Caroline McMillen. 

Millie McMillen was the mother of 8 children:

William R. "Willie" McMillen (1845-1923) married Nancy Hartness. Died in Cherokee County, NC
Rachel Louisa McMillen (1847-1910) married John Martin Hall, 7 children. Died in Polk County, Tennessee.
Joseph Frank McMillan (1846-1892) Married Lydia Roberts, 8 children. Died in Cherokee County, NC.
Stacy L. McMillan (1853-1908) married Napolean B. Graham, a Postmaster and Schoolteacher. Died in Polk County, TN. 3 children.
Carolina "Lina" McMillen (1856-after 1884) involved with William Crosier Graham, 1 son. May have married George Murphy. 
Nancy McMillen (1860-before 1870) Died in Cherokee County North Carolina.
Josephine Florence McMillen (1861-1921) Married Henry Dockery. Ten children. Died in Cherokee County North Carolina.
Carrie Emma McMillen (1869-1901) Married John William Cash. 3 children. Died in Knox County Tennessee.
John Lafayette McMillen (1876-1958) 7 children. Died in Cherokee County NC. 












No comments:

Post a Comment