The Mystery of the Mischievous Daisy Starnes

My Great, Great Great Aunt, Daisy Starnes, left a bit of a mystery. For certain, she appears in one census record as a child.

Name:	Dasie L. Starns [Dasie L. Starnes]
Age:	2
Birth Year:	abt 1878
Birthplace:	North Carolina
Home in 1880:	Rocky River, Cabarrus, North Carolina
Race:	White
Gender:	Female
Relation to Head of House:	Daughter
Marital Status:	Single
Father's name:	F.F. Starns
Father's Birthplace:	North Carolina
Mother's name:	Mary L. Starns
Mother's Birthplace:	North Carolina
Neighbors:	View others on page
Cannot read/write: Blind: Deaf and Dumb: Otherwise disabled: Idiotic or insane:	View image
Household Members:	Name Age F.F. Starns 51 Mary L. Starns 43 Margaret A. Starns 23 Thomas M. Starns 19 Dalphia A. Starns 10 Georgia A. Starns 7 Fredrick L. Starns 5 Dasie L. Starns 2 Martha Byram 70

Then, barely more than a child, she marries a Stanly County scoundrel, Joseph Marshall Herrin, at the young age of 15. Her father, F. F. Starnes, signed a consent for her to marry the man, and this has puzzled me. It does not appear something he would do.





After that, Daisy's story is told by way of newspaper articles.




First, they announce her marriage, then shortly afterwards, how it goes sour.







Daily Concord Standard
(Concord, North Carolina)6 Jun 1894, Wed • Page 2



According to the above article, the marriage of Joseph Marshall Herrin and Daisy Starnes really did not last very long. Young Daisy, who was only 15 when she married Joe Herrin, was tired of waiting on a convict husband to get out of jail and took off with her cousin Josephine Starnes Wallace's husband James.

The Evening Visitor
Raleigh, North Carolina)7 Jun 1894, Thu • Page 3


The Story was reported around the state.

Two years later, in 1896, the couple went to court and were found "Not Guilty".


The Concord Times
(Concord, North Carolina)
30 Jul 1896, Thu • Page 3

And that is the last I've found of Daisy Starnes Herrin. Her wayward husband, however, left more of a trail, and mentions her in abstract.


In the following article, it mentions that Joe Herrin had a living wife in either Mecklenburg County or Township 10, where Frederick Fincher Starnes lived, in Cabarrus County.


The Standard
(Concord, North Carolina)28 May 1896, Thu • Page 2

In this last off-handed mention of Daisy, she was "leading a life of ill fame" and at least alive in 1897. Joe Herrin divorced her and went on to marry 3 more times and his is a story of its own.



And what about Jim Wallace, the man Daisy took off to Gaston County with?

He at least went back to his wife Josephine "Josie " Starnes Wallace by 1900.

Name:	Josie Wallace [Jora Wallace]
Age:	28
Birth Date:	Apr 1871
Birthplace:	North Carolina
Home in 1900:	Poplar Tent, Cabarrus, North Carolina
Race:	White
Gender:	Female
Relation to Head of House:	Wife
Marital Status:	Married
Spouse's Name:	James Wallace
Marriage Year:	1887
Years Married:	13
Father's Birthplace:	North Carolina
Mother's Birthplace:	North Carolina
Mother: number of living children:	1
Mother: How many children:	2
Occupation:	View on Image
Neighbors:	View others on page
Household Members:	Name Age James Wallace 40 Josie Wallace 28 Beulah B Wallace 1/12

The census record tells us that the couple had a newborn daughter Beulah, and that Josie had been the mother of a second child that had already passed away. So Josie took him back. She was the daughter of Allen McDaniel (or A. M. D.) Starnes, son of Nathan T. Starnes. Josie, like her cousin Daisy, married early, and was only 14 when she married Jim Wallace. The marriage did not last long.

I have not yet discovered whether or not she divorced Jim Wallace or whether he died. He is hard to trace. Their marriage license gives his year of birth as 1867 and his parents as Robert D. and Elizabeth Wallace. The 1900 census gives his year of birth as 1850 and his place of birth as South Carolina and his parents as South Carolina. Wallace was a very common name in Cabarrus, Mecklenburg, Union Counties, NC and the northern counties of South Carolina. With the wide range of his possible birth date, it is difficult to determine which James or Jim Wallace he was.

What we do know is that Josephine married again, to the Rev. William H. Willeford on June 21, 1906. She may have been a widow, and her daughter had also passed away, because there is no other record of Beulah B. Wallace.

Name:	Josie Willeford
Age in 1910:	38
Birth Year:	abt 1872
Birthplace:	North Carolina
Home in 1910:	Township 11, Cabarrus, North Carolina
Race:	White
Gender:	Female
Relation to Head of House:	Wife
Marital Status:	Married
Spouse's Name:	William Willeford
Father's Birthplace:	North Carolina
Mother's Birthplace:	North Carolina
Neighbors:	View others on page
Household Members:	Name Age William Willeford 32 Josie Willeford 38

The couple lived in Burke County in 1920. The Rev. Willeford is buried in Davie County and passed away in 1927. 

Name:	Josephine Willeford [Josephine Williford]
Age:	47
Birth Year:	abt 1873
Birthplace:	North Carolina
Home in 1920:	Lovelady, Burke, North Carolina
Street:	South Main Street
Race:	White
Gender:	Female
Relation to Head of House:	Boarder
Marital Status:	Married
Father's Birthplace:	North Carolina
Mother's Birthplace:	North Carolina
Able to Speak English:	Yes
Occupation:	Cook
Industry:	Boarding House
Employment Field:	Wage or Salary
Neighbors:	View others on page
Household Members:	Name Age Ula Biggerstaff 36 [26]  William H Willeford 37 Josephine Willeford 47

Josie returned to Cabarrus County to live with family  and passed away in 1938.

Name:	Josie Willoford [Josie Willaford]
Birth Year:	abt 1873 [abt 1893]
Gender:	Female
Race:	White
Birthplace:	North Carolina
Marital Status:	Widowed
Relation to Head of House:	Aunt
Home in 1930:	Township 2, Cabarrus, North Carolina
Map of Home:	View Map
Dwelling Number:	187
Family Number:	187
Age at First Marriage:	25
Attended School:	No
Able to Read and Write:	No
Father's Birthplace:	North Carolina
Mother's Birthplace:	North Carolina
Able to Speak English:	Yes
Neighbors:	View others on page
Ho	Name Age Lawson C Carter 37 Maggie Carter 33 James Carter 16 Raymon Carter 14 Louise Carter 11 S Francis Carter 3 Bertha M Carter 0 Josie Willoford 57 [37]

Birth:	Apr. 16, 1872 Stanly County North Carolina, USA
Death:	Jun. 21, 1938 Cabarrus County North Carolina, USA

Josie's Starnes fate was fairly clear, but what of her cousin, the mysterious and mischeivous Daisy?

The Search Continues. 

The Joining of Mrs. Martha B.

Oftentimes, a bit of our heritage can be found in short blurbs in old books. Church histories make excellent references to our ancestors and offer invaluable insight into their way of life.

Rocky River Presbyterian Church is an old and well documented congregation located in Southwestern Cabarrus County, along the Rocky River, from which so much of my heritage sprang.

Several books of been written on it, and with mention of it, among the best and most thorough, one called "The Presbyterian Congregation on Rocky River". The author was Thomas Hugh Spence and it was published in 1954 by Rocky River Presbyterian Church of Concord, North Carolina.

The book in it's entirety is available online at this link :  https://archive.org/details/presbyteriancong00spen

through the Univeristy of North Carolina Chapel Hill library.

It includes over a paragraph on and an extensive review of the career and family of my 5th Great-Grandfather, Rev John McKemie Wilson. His middle name can be found spelled any number of ways, from McClema to MaKemie to McKamy and so forth. But it is not the reknowned Rev. Wilson that this post is on.

Instead, it's on a singular mention of an elderly and blind lady who had joined the church. That lady was my mysterious Fourth Great-Grandmother, Martha.

Now, I hesitate to give Martha's surname, even her married one, as I am not altogether positive what it was.

I have been researching it as "Byram", because the available information seemed to point in that direction. I also have only been able to find Martha in one census, the 1880 one, living with her daughter and son-in-law, Mary Louise and Frederick Fincher Starnes, my third Great-Grandparents.

NAME:	Martha Byram
AGE:	70
BIRTH YEAR:	abt 1810
BIRTHPLACE:	South Carolina
HOME IN 1880:	Rocky River, Cabarrus, North Carolina
RACE:	White
GENDER:	Female
RELATION TO HEAD OF HOUSE:	Mother-in-law
MARITAL STATUS:	Widowed
FATHER'S BIRTHPLACE:	South Carolina
MOTHER'S BIRTHPLACE:	South Carolina
NEIGHBORS:	View others on page
OCCUPATION:	Boarding
CANNOT READ/WRITE: BLIND: DEAF AND DUMB: OTHERWISE DISABLED: IDIOTIC OR INSANE:	View image
HOUSEHOLD MEMBERS:	NAME AGE F.F. Starns 51 Mary L. Starns 43 Margaret A. Starns 23 Thomas M. Starns 19 Dalphia A. Starns 10 Georgia A. Starns 7 Fredrick L. Starns 5 Dasie L. Starns 2 Martha Byram 70

This census, luckily, gives quite a bit of information on her. First, it identifies her as being 70 years old, having been born in South Carolina and her parents being born in South Carolina. It also names her as the mother-in-law of F. F. Starnes, meaning she was Mary L.'s mother. 

I do know that prior to F. F. Starnes showing up in Union County, NC in the 1860 census, living next to his father, Fred Jr. (son of Fred Sr.), he had purchased land along the Rocky River Road in Lancaster County, South Carolina and that his Civil War records identify him as being from both Union County, NC and Lancaster County, S.C. 

The documentation I've found on the children of Mary Louise Starnes seemed to corroborate the information in the census that her maiden name is Byram, or something very close, as the spellings vary. 

And now, I've found this mention of her in the Rocky River Presbyterian records. 

"A special meeting of the session was held at the residence of Frederick Starnes in February of 1875, at which time Mrs. Martha Bryson, "a blind and aged  lady" was recieved into the membership of the Church on confession of her faith. " pages 113-114, The Presbyterian Congregation at Rocky River. 

This was without any doubt, my Martha. First, at this time, Grandpa Finch was the only Fred Starnes living in that area, and he did live very near the church. Second, his wife and Martha's daughter, Mary Louise, is buried there, along with several of the children who died young. I am sure they were members of the church. 

Third, the 1880 census also identifies Martha as blind and her 7 year old granddaughter, Georgia, who would die young, as having rheumatism.  

I should be able to find Martha in an earlier census record, as the 1850, 1860, and 1870 census records all list women and children. By 1860, her daughter Mary Louise was married to F. F. and in 1850, we find a 14 year old girl, Mary L. Byrum, living with a 33 year old Elizabeth Byrom, a 70 year old Mary Byrom, and 28 year old laborer, Ephraim Starnes. Further research on Ephraim Starnes shows quite a bit of earlier interaction with a Willliam Byram, who was more than likely related to these 3 ladies. But no Martha, born around 1810. Was her name reallly Byram, as is shown in the census, or could it have been Bryson, as shown in the book?

On Mary L. , in the 1880 census, it reveals that she was born in North Carolina, as was her father, and verifies that her mother was born in South Carolina.

NAME:	Mary L. Starns [Mary L. Starnes]  [Mary L. Byram]
AGE:	43
BIRTH YEAR:	abt 1837
BIRTHPLACE:	North Carolina
HOME IN 1880:	Rocky River, Cabarrus, North Carolina
RACE:	White
GENDER:	Female
RELATION TO HEAD OF HOUSE:	Wife
MARITAL STATUS:	Married
SPOUSE'S NAME:	F.F. Starns
FATHER'S BIRTHPLACE:	North Carolina
MOTHER'S NAME:	Martha Byram
MOTHER'S BIRTHPLACE:	South Carolina
NEIGHBORS:	View others on page
OCCUPATION:	Keeping House
CANNOT READ/WRITE: BLIND: DEAF AND DUMB: OTHERWISE DISABLED: IDIOTIC OR INSANE:	View image
HOUSEHOLD MEMBERS:	NAME AGE F.F. Starns 51 Mary L. Starns 43 Margaret A. Starns 23 Thomas M. Starns 19 Dalphia A. Starns 10 Georgia A. Starns 7 Fredrick L. Starns 5 Dasie L. Starns 2 Martha Byram 70

The Death Certificate of Frederick Lafayette Starnes, known as "Fate", and shown as a 5 year old in the above census record, gives his mothers maiden name as "Brooms". Of course, the informant was son Silas Grier Starnes, who may not have been completely familiar with his Grandmother's maiden name, just the sound of it, and he also gave both of his father's parents as having been born in South Carolina.

In contrast, the death certificate of daughter Della (or Delphia) A. Starnes McAnnulty, gives her parents as "Fred Starnes" and "Mary Barren", the informant being her daughter, Stella.  This 1948 death certificate is in typed print, so there is no mistaking the lettering and granddaughter Stella gives the birthplace of her grandparents as "North Carolina". 

The 1936 Death Certificate of their brother, Thomas Mellon Starnes, gives his mother's maiden name as "Mary Byrums" and birthplaces for both parents being in "N. C." with the informant being his son Herbert Phillips Starnes. 

The death certificate for eldest daughter, Sarah Alice Starnes Linker, or Mrs. Wiley Monroe Linker, names her parents as F. F. Stearns and Mary Byron. 

Oddly, although my Second G-Grandmother Leavy, lived the longest other than one brother, passing in 1939, I've yet to locate a death certificate for her. Either the year is wrong on her tombstone, her name was horribly mangled on the certificate, or she just slipped by without one. 

Also missing is daughter Daisy L Starnes who married Joseph M. Herrin. I can not locate her past her 1893 marriage license, but her story does not end there. 

So what was Grandma Martha's last name? Byron, Bryson, Byram, Barren?

......the search goes on.